Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
🎁 Quick Gift List
- Lip Smackers Lip Balm
- Mochi Squishies
- Initial Keychains
- Butter/cloud slime
- Crazy Aaron’s Mini Thinking Putty
- Invisible Ink Pens
- Friendship Bracelets
- Cute Sticker Packs
Planning a birthday party is fun. Filling the loot bags? Not always.
After spending money on decorations, cake, and activities, it can be frustrating to end up with a bag full of tiny plastic toys that break before guests even get home.
The best loot bag fillers are the ones kids are genuinely excited about and actually use after the party is over.
Whether you’re planning a princess party, animal-themed birthday, sleepover, or just need easy party favors for a classroom celebration, these are some of our favorite loot bag ideas for girls ages 5–10.
Lip Smackers
I remember getting Lip Smackers as a kid and feeling incredibly grown up. They’re still just as popular today. Kids love comparing flavors, trading with friends, and tossing one into a backpack or pencil case. They’re inexpensive, easy to divide between loot bags, and somehow always feel like a special treat.
Mochi Squishies
I wasn’t expecting much from these the first time I bought them, but the kids were obsessed. They got squeezed during car rides, tucked into pockets, brought to school, and somehow ended up everywhere in the house. They’re tiny, inexpensive, and have way more staying power than most loot bag fillers.
Friendship Bracelets
Friendship bracelets are one of those party favors that kids actually wear instead of tossing aside five minutes later. The fun starts before they even leave the party—everyone immediately starts comparing designs and choosing their favorites. They feel a little more special than typical loot bag toys and make great keepsakes from a birthday celebration.
Initial Keychains
Anything personalized instantly feels more exciting. I’ve noticed kids gravitate toward these right away, searching for their own letter and showing it off to friends. They’re cute, practical, and easy to clip onto backpacks or lunch bags, making them a favor that sticks around long after the party ends.
Invisible Ink Pens
These are one of those classic kid favorites that somehow never go out of style. I remember writing secret messages and feeling like a spy, and kids today seem just as fascinated. The built-in UV light makes ordinary notes feel mysterious and turns simple doodling into an activity.
Butter Slime Kit
Slime is practically a guaranteed win at any kid’s party. The butter slime version is especially fun because it’s soft, stretchy, and much less sticky than traditional slime. Kids love mixing colors, adding decorations, and creating their own little slime masterpieces. If your child enjoys sensory play, this is usually one of the first items they’ll pull out of their loot bag.
Crazy Aaron’s Mini Thinking Putty
This is one of those favors that surprises adults and kids alike. The first time we tried it, everyone at the table ended up playing with it. It stretches, bounces, twists, and keeps little hands busy without creating a mess. The mini tins are perfect for loot bags and feel noticeably more premium than standard putty.
Sticker Packs
I used to underestimate stickers until I realized how quickly kids use them. Water bottles, notebooks, binders, bedroom doors—everything becomes fair game. A big sticker pack gives kids plenty to choose from, and unlike many party favors, they actually get used instead of forgotten in a drawer.
Final Thoughts
The best loot bags don’t have to be expensive.
A few thoughtful items that kids genuinely enjoy will almost always be more memorable than a bag stuffed with random trinkets.
We try to focus on loot bag fillers that are fun, affordable, and likely to get used after the party ends. These favorites strike that balance perfectly and work well for girls across a wide range of ages and interests.
Happy party planning!
Looking for more birthday and gift ideas? Check out: